Did John Lennon Say Ringo “Wasn’t Even The Best Drummer In The Beatles”?

9 October 2018, 01:30 | Updated: 9 October 2018, 01:31

The Beatles, 1969
The Beatles, 1969. Picture: Hans J. Hoffmann/ullstein bild via Getty Images

Did Lennon really make this famous joke at the expense of his Beatle pal? Let’s find out…

It’s one of the standing jokes in the music industry. And it reportedly came from the mouth of John Lennon himself:

“Ringo wasn’t the best drummer in the world… Let’s face it, he wasn’t even the best drummer in The Beatles”

Now Lennon was known for his caustic wit, and this is a prime example of how biting he could be - even having a pop at his former Beatle colleague.

But did John Lennon actually make that joke?

John Lennon and Yoko Ono, 1969
John Lennon and Yoko Ono, 1969. Picture: Mondadori Portfolio by Getty Images

Some Beatlologists claim that despite John having a barbed sense of humour, even that seems like a step too far for him. After all, following the acrimonious split of The Beatles in 1970, Ringo performed on solo albums by both John AND George Harrison.

But nobody seems to have been able to find actual evidence of Lennon ever saying the words. And now we know why.

The joke also relies on a couple of assumptions: firstly, that you think that Ringo is a rubbish drummer, something that quite plainly isn’t true. Starr was definitely not from the jazz school of percussion, but his distinctive thwack - particularly in the experimental days of Revolver and Sgt Pepper - influenced a generation.

Ringo Starr, 1965
Ringo Starr, 1965. Picture: Mondadori Portfolio by Getty Images

The joke also assumes that you know there was another drummer in the Fab Four: namely, Paul McCartney, who was a mean sticksman himself, having stepped into the breach when Ringo had temporarily flounced (Back In The USSR) or simply wasn’t available (The Ballad Of John And Yoko).

For a long time, some Beatle experts claimed that the joke was actually coined by comedian Jasper Carrott around 1983, when he was appearing regularly on the BBC in a show called Carrott’s Lib.

Jasper Carrott in 1981
Jasper Carrott in 1981. Picture: Michael Putland/Getty Images

But now it seems like we’re closer to the source. Pop culture journalist Tim Worthington was making his way through an old Radio 4 comedy series called Radio Active, when there, all present and correct in a 1981 edition, was the “Ringo isn’t the best drummer in The Beatles” joke.

Beatle scholar Mark Lewisoh (author of the definitive Fab Four book Tune In: All These Years) did some further digging and turned up the actual episode itself, dated 6 October 1981:

The programme was a parody of bad local radio and starred Angus Deayton in his pre-Have I Got News For You days. The gag itself was made by Phil Pope, later better known for his musical numbers in Spitting Image, including the immortal Chicken Song.

Lewisohn confirmed that BBC paperwork credits the script to Geoffrey Perkins, who had produced the original radio series of The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy and worked on Spitting Image, Have I Got News For You and Father Ted.

Perkins died in 2008 at the tragically young age of 55, but his classic Ringo-baiting gag now gets the recognition it deserves!

The Beatles Songs